Jesse H. Neal Award
Jesse H. Neal Award
2014, 2013, 2012,
2011, 2010, 2009
Best Publication and
Best How-to Article
BUILDINGS SUBSCRIP TION INFORMATION RATES:
United States and its possessions: $120.00 for
1 year. All foreign countries $150.00 (US funds)
(surface mail) for 1 year. Extra and back issue
copies (when available) are $10.00 each, shipping
and handling included – except on large/bulk
shipments. Tear sheets $1.75 each. All orders must
be PREPAID to: BUILDINGS magazine, 615 Fifth
St SE, Cedar Rapids IA 52401 or PO Box 1888,
Cedar Rapids IA 52406-1888. Attn: Subscription
Department. 1-800-553-8878 ext. 5020.
Copyright 2016 Stamats Communications.
For high-quality, customized reprints,
please contact Stamats Marketing Services:
1-800-553-8878 ext. 5034
The Stamats headquarters
is a LEED Certified Silver
IS A PROUD MEMBER OF: nBUILDINGS
Volume 111 Number 9 BUILDINGS (ISSN 2471-3112) is published monthly by Stamats Communications 615 5th St. SE, PO Box 1888, Cedar Rapids, IA, 52406-1888;
(319) 364-6167. Periodicals Postage Paid at Cedar Rapids, IA, and at additional mailing office. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to: Buildings, PO Box 1888,
Cedar Rapids, IA, 52406-1888. Publications mail agreement No. 41666041. Return undeliverable Canadian addresses to: PO Box 875, S TN A, Windsor, ON, N9A 6P2.
A Publication of Stamats Buildings Media
Group Publisher Tony Dellamaria
Chief Content Director Chris Olson
Senior Editor Janelle Penny
Associate Editor Justin Feit
E-Content Editor Keith Evanson
Art Director Elisa Geneser
Senior Graphic Designer Evan Bro wnfield
For subscriptions, visit:
Buildings is a registered trademark owned by
Editorial Advisory Board
Christopher K. Ahoy President/CEO,
Performance Management Consulting
Steven R. Colvin Senior Vice President of
Property Management, Boston Properties LP
Michael Delev General Property Manager, Hines
Rod Stevens Principal Consultant,
Eric A. Woodroof Founder,
FROM the EDITOR
A fire with much loss of life and property, like the recent
one at Grenfell Tower in London, captures international
attention. And in particular, fires in high-rise buildings
are high-profile events. Perhaps they suggest the possibility of greater
disaster due to the sheer building size. A high-rise fire was the core of the plot in a top-grossing film,
The Towering Inferno. Nevertheless, life and property damage from fire is, on average, significantly less
in high-rises than low-rises. The reasons underscore the factors at work in fires and how FMs can best
manage the risks.
The likely place of origin of a fire is much the same in both commercial high-rise and low-rises.
According to the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA), a kitchen or cooking area is, by far, the
single most likely place. In high-rise structures, a kitchen accounts for 76% of fires in apartments, 40% in
hotels, 65% in dorms and 31% in offices. In low-rise structures, those percentages are very similar.
What differs is the likelihood of fire spread and damage beyond the place of origin. Low-rises are
more than twice as likely as high-rises to have fire spread. In apartment structures, only 4% of high-rise
cases have fire spread but 10% of low-rises do. NFPA reports similar figures for other property types. In
hotels, 4% of high-rise fires result in flame spread but 11% of low-rise fires; in office buildings, it is 10%
vs. 21%. In turn, the fire death rate and average property loss per 1,000 fires are generally higher in low-rises than in high-rises of the same property type.
NFPA theorizes that high-rises are more likely to have fire-resistive construction and wet pipe
sprinklers to limit flame spread. Exceptions can be costly. In the fire at the former MGM Grand hotel in
Las Vegas, which killed 85 people, sprinklers were not installed in the restaurant where the fire began.
The reasoning of building inspectors was that spaces that were occupied 24/7 did not need them—a
fire would be discovered quickly and put out with portable fire extinguishers. Unfortunately, the restaurant was closed when vibrations from refrigeration equipment frayed the insulation on electrical wiring.
Moreover, one cannot be sure that fire bottles will work when needed. In the early minutes of an arson
fire that killed eight at the former Las Vegas Hilton, a faulty extinguisher defeated the efforts of a hotel
Anticipating where fires are most likely to occur is clearly important, as are inspection and maintenance of fire systems. Last month, NFPA released a report on the effectiveness of sprinklers. In the 12%
of fires in which sprinklers failed to operate or operated inadequately, the majority of cases involved
damaged system components, deficient maintenance or—incredibly—the system was shut off.
For some insights into effective maintenance and inspection routines, read our guide for FMs
beginning on page 36.
Chief Content Director